TEST METHODS FOR BIODEGRADATION

 

As major ingredients in detergents worldwide, surfactants can enter the environment in small amounts after sewage or septic system treatment. Tests for biodegradation are used to predict how quickly and completely chemicals will break d own in the environment. However, these tests can underestimate a chemical's ability to biodegrade if they do not examine real-world factors, such as the effects of wastewater treatment or microorganism acclimation. Because biodegradability is widely recog nized as an indicator of environmental safety, it is critical that realistic test conditions be used to determine biodegradability.

  • The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is leading international efforts to standardize biodegradation test methods. The OECD has published six tests on ready biodegradability, includi ng 301C: The Modified MITI Test (I); four tests on inherent biodegradability; and one simulation test for aerobic sewage treatment.(1,2)
  • A pending European Community (EC) directive to determine criteria for ultimate biodegradation proposes use of the OECD ready biodegradability tests. However, European detergent producers (AIS) and suppliers (CESIO) believe tha t these tests are not an accurate indicator of natural environments and have proposed using a continuous activated sludge test for environmental risk assessment. This method allows bacterial acclimation and, therefore, is more characteristic of real world environmental conditions.(1)
  • Most controversial is the Modified MITI Test (I) for ready biodegradation, which specifies conditions for detergent ingredients that include abnormally high test substance concentrations and very little time for microorganisms to acclimate to test conditions. This test has been criticized because the methodology specifies conditions that do not occur in nature, and thus is an unreliable predictor of environmental fate.(3)
  • Commercial linear alkylbenzene sulfonate (LAS) passes all OECD tests except for the Modified MITI Test (I).(4,5) Like most tests for ready biodegradability, the Modified MITI Test (I) is designated to quickly estima te the rate of biodegradation.(6)
  • According to OECD guidelines, negative results on screening tests do not indicate that a compound will not biodegrade in the environment. Rather, such results mean that establishing biodegradability will require more comprehen sive testing, such as the inherent biodegradability tests or the sewage treatment simulation tests. Commercial LAS passes all OECD tests for inherent biodegradability as well as the OECD Simulation Test.(4,5)
  • As a result, LAS is classified as "readily biodegradable," according to both the OECD guidelines and the EC's registration terminology for new chemicals.(7)
  • Both the OECD tests and the Modified Gledhill Test are referenced in the premanufacturing notification requirements of the U.S. Toxic Substance Control Act (TSCA) of 1976. Commercial LAS passes the Modified Gledhill Test. (4,5)
  • Commercial LAS also passes the shake-flask and semi-continuous activated sludge (SCAS) tests of the U.S. Soap and Detergent Association and the American Society for Testing and Materials.(1,4,5)
  • Used in detergents worldwide, LAS is clearly shown through reliable test methods to biodegrade rapidly and completely in the environment. This finding is further supported through real-world monitoring and 30 years of safe use .
KEY REFERENCES

1. Britton, L. in Biodegradation: How Does It Apply to Cleaning Products? (The Soap and Detergent Association) 20-30 (New York, 1993); HAPPI 30(5) 110-113 (May, 1993).

2. Swift, G. in Biodegradation: How Does It Apply to Cleaning Products? (The Soap and Detergent Association) 10-19 (New York, 1993); HAPPI 30(5) 106-109 (May, 1993).

3. Gledhill, W. E., M. L. Trehy and D. B. Carson. Chemosphere 22, 873-880 (1991).

4. Monsanto, unpublished data.

5. CONDEA Vista, unpublished data.

6. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. "OECD Guidelines for Testing of Chemicals," First Addendum, ISBN: 92-64-12221-4 (May 1993).

7. BKH Consulting Engineers. "Environmental Fate and Behavior of LAS." Literature Review, ECOSOL, Brussels. (Delft, May 24, 1993).

Last updated on May 1996

# # #

INDEX OF CLER FACT SHEETS

Contact Us
The CLER.com website is not compatible with Internet Explorer 6. We recommend that you upgrade or download Firefox to view the site.